Home/ Journal/ When to replace

When to replace

When to replace cedar: five signs it is ready to compost

Cedar does not last forever, but it lasts a lot longer than most people think. Here is how to tell when it is honestly done — and what to do with it after.

November 2026 · 2 min read

Western red cedar in daily wardrobe use lasts us, on average, two to three years. Some pieces go longer; a few go shorter. The wood doesn't disintegrate — the oil simply runs out. Here are the five signs that it is finally time.

1. No scent comes back after sanding

This is the only test that matters. Sand a block with the sponge and sniff. If you get a soft cedar note, it is still working. If you get the smell of plain, dry wood, the oil is gone. Replace it.

2. The surface stays grey no matter how deep you sand

A fresh sand should always expose a pale, honey-coloured wood underneath. If the grey goes all the way through, the whole piece has oxidised. It is done.

3. Cracking or splitting along the grain

Cedar is a soft wood. A few fine cracks are normal. But deep splits, or a hanger that twists in your hand, means the wood has dried past the useful point. Compost it.

4. Mould, mildew, or damp spots

Rare, but it happens — usually in boxes that got packed away damp. If you see dark spots, soft patches, or a musty smell under the cedar smell, don't try to rescue it. Any wool it was protecting should be washed too, since damp wool is itself a moth magnet.

ShortcutIf a piece feels lighter than it did when it was new, it is almost certainly ready. The oil is most of the weight you lose.

5. More than three years in use, even if the other four signs look fine

At some point, the wood is just tired. If a piece is older than three years in daily wardrobe service, replace it on principle. The small cost is nothing against the sweater it is protecting.

What to do with old cedar

Three options, in order of preference:

  1. Compost it. Cedar is untreated, uncoated wood. Break the piece up and put it on the pile. It finishes as mulch in about a year.
  2. Mulch a border with it. Chipped cedar is a lovely garden mulch — and it keeps some insects away from seedlings too.
  3. Burn it, carefully. On a fire, outdoors, as kindling. It smells wonderful. Do not use it in a woodburner that vents into a room — the oil smoke is lovely in the garden, less lovely in a lung.

That's it. Replace, compost, start again. The whole cycle takes under a minute of thought, and keeps a wardrobe moth-free for the cost of a tenner a year.

Keep the moths out, the old way.

Natural cedar and lavender. No chemicals, no mothball smell. Loved by 10,000+ wardrobes on Amazon.

More from the journal

The 3-Month Sand: the one habit that keeps cedar working Where moths actually hide — and where to put your cedar first